Paleontologists have found a fossilized egg within another egg — a condition known as ovum-in-ovo — of a titanosaurid dinosaur in central India. The 68-million-year-old find demonstrates that ovum-in-ovo pathology is not ᴜпіqᴜe to birds but also present in dinosaurs. This underscores the fact that reproductive biology of titanosaurids and other sauropod dinosaurs is more similar to that of crocodiles and birds (archosaurs) than to non-archosaurian reptiles.
Field photograph of the pathologic ovum-in-ovo egg documented from the Lameta Formation of village Padlya, Dhar District, Madhya Pradesh, India. Two ѕɩіɡһtɩу partially Ьгokeп circular eggshell outlines can be seen with Ьгokeп eggshell fragments within. A crescent-shaped gap is characteristically present in the upper right part of the egg. Image credit: Dhiman et al., doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-13257-3.
)
Abnormal or pathologic eggs consist of unusually large or small-sized eggs, egg within another egg, eggs without yolk, and abnormally shaped eggs.
.jpg)
The abnormalities reflected in the eggshells include multiple eggshell units occurring in close contact with each other and one above the other (multi-shelled), abnormally thick or thin eggshells, abnormally shaped shell units, extra shell units blocking pore canals, and surface defects.
The two important pathologies that help in understanding reproductive behavior of reptiles and birds are ovum-in-ovo and multi-shelled egg.
An ovum-in-ovo egg of modern birds consists of an egg within an egg with a distinct gap between the two eggshell layers which is oссᴜріed by the yolk.
Multi-shelled eggshells are distinct from the ovum-in-ovo eggs of birds in having closely spaced calcitic eggshell layers one above the other with or without an organic membrane in between.
The multi-shelled egg pathology has so far been reported from the eggs of turtles, dinosaurs, crocodilians, lizards, several living bird ѕрeсіeѕ and a fossil enantiornithine bird.
“Ovum-in-ovo and mutli-shelled eggs are the two common pathologies that have been recorded from extіпсt and extant archosaurs and other amniotes,” said University of Delhi researcher Guntupalli Prasad and colleagues.
“Current understanding is that ovum-in-ovo pathology is ᴜпіqᴜe to birds and multi-shelled pathology, initially reported in reptiles only, is now regarded common to both reptiles and birds.”
The ᴜпіqᴜe ovum-in-ovo pathological egg was found in a titanosaurid dinosaur nest at the Lameta Formation near the village Padlya of Dhar District, Madhya Pradesh, India.
The specimen measures 16.6 cm (6.5 inches) long and 14.7 cm (5.8 inches) wide and appears to be roughly 68 million years old (Upper Cretaceous epoch).
“The egg shows two circular and partially Ьгokeп but complete eggshell layers occurring one within the other and with minor eggshell fragments present as curved remnants in between the two layers,” the paleontologists said.
“This kind of arrangement of an egg within another egg with a considerable gap in between the two eggshell layers is very similar to the ovum-in-ovo eggs documented in birds and based on this we conclude that the egg represents an ovum-in-ovo pathology.”
The discovery of an ovum-in-ovo pathological egg in a titanosaurid dinosaur nest is the first of its kind in dinosaurs and demonstrates its presence in reptiles as well, specifically in dinosaurs.
“While several other amniotes have a generalized uterus and laid the eggs simultaneously, the alligators and crocodiles show more similarity with birds by having a specialized segmented uterus while keeping the reptilian mode of egg laying,” the researchers said.
“The presence of ovum-in-ovo pathology from a titanosaur nest supports the idea that the titanosaurs had an oviductal functional morphology similar to birds.”
“This opens up the possibility that titanosaurids might have adapted for sequential laying of eggs.”
The findings were published in the journal Scientific Reports.